A question we are often asked is, can you bake and fry with olive oil? If you don't feel like reading this whole story, our short answer is: yes! A lot and often! Very healthy! But only with extra virgin olive oil!
People regularly come up to me and say; "I don't know much about olive oil but one thing I do know, you shouldn't bake or fry with olive oil! Right?" Sorry, but nothing could be further from the truth. In this blog, I will explain, and support with scientific studies, why you should indeed bake and fry with good extra virgin olive oil.
Is cooking with extra virgin olive oil healthy? Science tells us.
Most Dutch people, as a collective, are convinced that you shouldn't bake and fry with extra virgin olive oil. But, if you ask if olive oil is used for baking and frying in Spain, Greece, or Italy, everyone says yes, of course! So where does the collective idea come from that you shouldn't bake and fry with olive oil? It's a mystery. Even the Dutch Nutrition Centre has unthinkingly adopted this misconception, while science has been demonstrating for years that extra virgin olive oil is the most stable, safe, and healthy oil to bake and fry with.
Among others, this Australian study shows that extra virgin olive oil is the safest and healthiest oil for baking and frying. Even with longer heating, extra virgin olive oil remains healthy (read here) and here is a study that shows that even after 6 hours at 180 °C, olive oil is the safest, healthiest oil. But always use a premium extra virgin olive oil and nothing of lesser quality.
A premium extra virgin olive oil belongs in every kitchen and is versatile for cold and hot dishes. If you are going to bake and fry at temperatures of 180 – 220 °C, it is important to know which olive oil is best to use and how hot you can let it get. If you want to know more, then read on. Welcome to the world of olive oil!
Baking and Frying with Olive Oil
Baking and frying with extra virgin olive oil? Isn't that just for salads? Certainly, but a good home cook doesn't just use extra virgin olive oil in salads. It's no coincidence that you see all those TV chefs drizzling extra virgin olive oil over everything, including in pots and pans on the stove and in the oven. Look at Gordon Ramsay and Jamie Oliver, for example. Both British celebrity chefs with dozens of restaurants and just as many Michelin stars. All good extra virgin olive oil is suitable for cold and hot use!
Almost every dish tastes better when you use good extra virgin olive oil! And it doesn't have to be limited to Mediterranean cuisine or dishes from your new Jamie Oliver or Ottolenghi cookbook. Even our perfectly normal, slightly boring, Dutch boiled vegetables, like green beans, cauliflower, and broccoli, but also boiled potatoes for example, instantly get more flavor by drizzling some delicious extra virgin olive oil over them. Much healthier than gravy and you immediately enjoy more flavor. Sunshine on your plate!
But don't use olive oil from the supermarket. It's almost never good and probably unhealthy! We explain why in this blog: "Good Olive Oil from the Supermarket". Also, never use the 'olive oil' in plastic, transparent bottles, whether or not it's supposedly suitable for hot use! That's refined oil, which is almost always made from rotten and pest-infested olives (see the Keuringsdienst van Waarde video). The sludge that remains after pressing has to be heated, chemically cleaned, chemically decolorized, and then colored and diluted with a few percent real olive oil so that the producer can put 'olive oil' on the label. You don't want to eat that! See below for more.
What is baking and frying?
Baking and frying is often used as an all-encompassing term for what happens in pots, pans, the oven, and the deep fryer. In this blog, baking and frying refers to the specific temperature that usually starts at 190+ °C and then drops to 140-160 °C. This means baking and frying starts at a higher temperature than, for example, deep frying. Deep frying is best done at a maximum of 175-180 °C.
The right temperature is important because the best properties of many foods, such as meat, emerge when they are cooked at the right temperature. Above 190 °C, your fries will burn, but a steak needs 190 °C to brown nicely. And that outer layer is important.
When food is cooked at the right temperature, the sugars on the outside caramelize and the natural proteins turn into a thin skin that protects the food from absorbing the oil. It is therefore important to start at the right temperature. Not too low, because the fries will soak up the oil, and not too hot, because the outside will burn before the inside reaches the right temperature.
When baking and frying in olive oil or fat, it is advisable to use an oil or fat that can withstand at least 190 °C, and preferably a little higher, so that you have some margin and it doesn't immediately start smoking and becoming toxic if you're not paying attention for a moment.
Frying meat in olive oil
You can rub meat and fish with good olive oil before placing them in a hot pan. This is called searing.
How does this technique work?
-
Rub meat with olive oil
You apply a thin layer of oil directly to the meat. This ensures that:- the meat does not stick to the pan;
- herbs and salt adhere well;
- the outside browns more evenly.
-
Hot surface + short time
Then you place the meat in a very hot pan, which causes:- the outside to quickly sear (Maillard reaction);
- an aromatic brown crust to form;
- the meat to remain juicy on the inside.
Why not oil in the pan?
That can be done, of course, but oil directly on the meat provides:
- better contact between oil and the meat's surface;
- less splatter;
- often more even browning.
Different types of olive oil
For baking and frying in olive oil, you therefore need the right olive oil that can withstand 190+ °C. Good extra virgin olive oil contains components that protect the olive oil from burning. If you use the wrong olive oil, such as the cheap one from the supermarket, you run the risk of it becoming very unhealthy very quickly. Here's a link to our blog about good olive oil from the supermarket (spoiler alert; it doesn't exist!).
Roughly speaking, olive oil can be distinguished into 3 types: extra virgin olive oil, virgin olive oil, and refined olive oil. Refined olive oil can be made from lampante olive oil or pomace olive oil. Both are not suitable for consumption, but through heating, chemical artistry, and a few percent of extra virgin olive oil added, it can still be sold as olive oil. Bizarre but true. More about refined olive oil will be discussed below.
The only olive oil you should use in the kitchen and on the table is extra virgin olive oil! According to several scientific studies (see references), baking and frying in extra virgin olive oil is the healthiest of all fats and oils.
Extra virgin olive oil is made from the right type of olives processed in the right way. It is not the cheapest olive oil and, with the exception that proves the rule, not available in supermarkets.
By the way, "extra vierge" is the same as "extra virgin", "extra vergine", and "Vergin extra". Extra vierge is French, extra virgin is English, extra vergine is Italian, and vergin extra is Spanish. Since 'extra virgin' (literally translated) doesn't sound very appealing, we borrow the terms from abroad. Most people in the Netherlands prefer the French variant; extra vierge. But the English variant; extra virgin, is also becoming more common.
Virgin olive oil, meaning without "extra", is olive oil of slightly lower quality that does not meet the legal requirements set by the EU for Extra virgin olive oil. "Extra virgin" may have a maximum acidity of 0.8%, while "virgin" olive oil may have a maximum acidity of 3%. Acidity is the amount of acidic, and thus bad, oil that an olive oil may contain. So Extra means extra good.
Actually, you could perfectly well bake and fry in good virgin olive oil (i.e., without the extra), but it's not available in the Netherlands. In 99% of cases, virgin olive oil is oil that is not actually suitable for consumption but has been so chemically processed and manipulated that it just meets the European standard. Just like sunflower oil. Real sunflower oil, which you might buy from a farmer in France, is delicious! What we can buy in supermarkets in the Netherlands has nothing to do with that. The Keuringsdienst van Waarde made an excellent broadcast about this. Click here to watch the episode.

